Thursday, November 19, 2009

BBA Challenge: Whole Wheat English Muffins

I've always enjoyed English Muffins, but they aren't something I ever remember to buy. I was really excited to make my own for the BBA Challenge. They looked simple enough, and they are cooked in a skillet before being transferred to the oven to bake through which looked like a lot of fun to do.

English Muffins were supposed to have been posted oh, I don't know, a month or so ago... I made them on schedule, but they were a total flop. I felt defeated and deflated and hadn't made bread since. Then I saw Nancy's post on her English Muffins and I was inspired to try again.

Everything that went wrong the first time - they were huge and round like rolls, they burned on both sides in the skillet, they had no flavor - was remedied this time around. To combat the lack of flavor, I used 5oz whole wheat bread flour and 5oz unbleached white flour. This added a wonderful complexity that was earthy, a little sweet, and very hearty. Once I put my risen dough balls into the skillet, I pressed them down with a spatula to flatten them. I may have lost my nooks and crannies that are typical of English Muffins, but I much preferred them this way. I think I may have had my burner on too high the first time around, hence the burning, so I was very careful to have a rather low flame for their time in the pan. I also used salted butter instead of oil, and let me tell you what a brilliant idea that was! It added just a hint of saltiness, that played so well off of the crunchy caramelized spots on the crust. So, so good.

I am very pleased to say that I really look forward to making these again. Though I'll probably double the batch and freeze some, because they are already gone (and were only baked last night!).

The recipe for these English Muffins can be found in The Bread Baker's Apprentice by Peter Reinhart. A must-have book if you enjoy baking bread at home.


  1. OH!! Sarah. WWF and salted butter. These probably added TONS of flavor. Next time I make, will have to try your version.

    They look perfect.

  2. these look wonderful!! Thanks for the great tips! I am hoping to get BBA for Christmas- I'm going to try to bake all of our bread at home for the whole year.

  3. Your muffins look so delicious Sarah! Glad you decided to give them another shot and that you were so successful the second time around. I want to try these again with some whole wheat flour and maybe honey.

  4. Oh yum, I tried making muffins a while ago and failed too. I think I'll try your way. Keep fingers cross for a success in my kitchen too.

    Oh, I could just eat one now with grated cheese on top. Tummy rumbling at the thought.

  5. Love your version of the whole wheat. I need to try these as whole wheat ones...look great and I absolutely love making English muffins!

  6. Glad these ones worked for you- they look perfect

  7. Those look great, Sarah. I want to try English muffins again one of these days. I wasn't very happy with my first batch either.


Related Posts with Thumbnails