I was never a child who liked PB&Js - I'd take stir fried veggies and basmati rice any day. The only way I've ever enjoyed peanut butter is in cookies, and I really love them. The first peanut butter cookies I ever made were from Baked a few weeks ago, and they were unbelievable, so I was excited to see this recipe pop up on the schedule.
These seem to me to be pretty classic peanut butter cookies, and they were very yummy - nice and soft on the inside, chewy, firm around the edges. Delicious. The Baked cookies still rank as my favorite, but these are right up there.
The were easy as could be, though they did take longer to bake than the recipe instructed. It calls for 10 minutes, but even at 12, mine were so soft they fell apart even when cool. They needed more like 14 minutes, and then they were perfect.
Check out Stephanie's blog Ice Cream Before Dinner for the recipe for these yummy cookies.
Those cookies look delish. I'm going to have to try the Baked version since it's your favorite. I liked these cookies a lot more than I expected to.
ReplyDeleteI cooked mine for around 14 minutes (due to their massive size) and they were perfect!
ReplyDeleteYours look amazing!
Katie xox
I loved these cookies. Your cookies look great! I doubled this recipe and Im so glad I did!
ReplyDeleteGreat pic. It's amazing how ovens vary.
ReplyDeleteGreat photo - your cookies look terrific! I totally agree on the cooking time for these - mine were up around 14 or 15 minutes.
ReplyDeleteI loved these cookies. Yours look so good.
ReplyDeleteThose cookies look yummy!
ReplyDeleteLove the golden brown color in your cookies. I found my cookies to be a bit pale-looking. Maybe I should try using all brown sugar next time.
ReplyDeleteI cant believe you didnt like PB&J growing up?! Your cookies look great! I'll have to look into Baked ones!
ReplyDeleteglad you like the cookies! the look great!
ReplyDeleteOoh, I love evertyhing I've made from the Baked book so far, I'll have to give their PB Cookies a shot!
ReplyDeleteYour cookies look delicious! I had to bake mine for around fourteen minutes as well. I'll have to try the Baked recipe. I love anything with peanut butter in it.
ReplyDeleteMine fell apart because I was so careful not to over bake them, LOL. Your cookies look yummy!!
ReplyDeleteYour cookies look just perfect!
ReplyDeleteHi Sarah!
ReplyDeleteSo good to hear from you :) Your cookies look absolutely delish- great job! I just purchased a copy of Baked after eyeing it for the past year, and I can't wait to start baking from it. I'll definitely have to try the PB cookies, if they have your recommendation. Any other recipes that are a must-try?
Hope to hear from you again soon- this weekend's SMS is Snickerdoodles, so it looks like we'll be filling up the cookie jar twice in a row!
-Joy